[37] On Metacritic it has a score of 56% based on reviews from 5 critics, indicating "mixed or average reviews". Who knew? We are used to climate science misinformation campaigns from fossil fuel corporations. Directed by Jeff Gibb and produced by Michael Moore, Planet of the Humans explores the environmental movement and how it has failed to fix environmental concerns such as climate change. Planet of the Humans review – contrarian eco-doc from the Michael Moore stable Jeff Gibbs’ film, produced by Michael Moore, takes a pop at green, liberal A … The film shows green tech investor Robert F. Kennedy Jr. speaking to an oil and gas industry group stating, “The plants that we’re building, the wind plants and the solar plants, are gas plants.”, Zehner discusses how companies including Apple and Tesla claim to run on 100% renewable energy despite remaining hooked up to the grid and reveals the Koch Brothers' involvement in green technology production. Gibbs visits Steven Running, an ecologist from the University of Montana, who discusses planetary limits – including global fish production, agricultural land, water irrigation, and ground water. and "Mainstream enviros will hate this movie because it exposes some of their real failings. ", "Planet of the Humans: Why Technology Won't Save Us", "Michael Moore: Mother Nature sending warning, people to 'time-out rooms' with pandemic", "Michael Moore, filmmakers respond to criticism of new bombshell environmental film", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Planet_of_the_Humans&oldid=1011515923, Documentary films about alternative energy, Short description is different from Wikidata, Wikipedia articles needing clarification from May 2020, Articles lacking reliable references from June 2020, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, This page was last edited on 11 March 2021, at 08:50. [33], In a letter, filmmaker and environmental activist Josh Fox and academics including climate scientist Michael Mann have asked for an apology and a retraction of the film. Environmentalist Bill McKibben responded to claims made in the documentary about him and the organization he cofounded, 350.org: "A Youtube video emerged on Earth Day eve making charges about me and about 350.org — namely that I was a supporter of biomass energy, and that 350 and I were beholden to corporate funding, and have misled our supporters on the costs and trade-offs related to decarbonizing our economy. Obwohl gut gedreht und bearbeitet, ist das Material hier einfach zu umfangreich, als dass man sich nicht in ein unbeholfenes Paket gezwängt fühlen könnte, selbst Erzähler Gibbs gibt zu, dass es "überwältigend wirken könnte". [54] Jacobin wrote that the film "embraces bad science on renewable energy and anti-humanist, anti–working class narratives of overpopulation and overconsumption", concluding that by "focusing on industrial civilization and 'overpopulation' as the cause of environmental problems, Moore and Gibbs distract us from the real problem: the untrammeled market. Grantham was already a mega-rich investor before he “got religion” on environmental issues. and stated that "This cri de coeur from American producer-composer-editor Gibbs may lack balance and counterarguments, but it convincingly makes the case that “less must be the new more” if humankind is to have any chance of not being wiped out due to overpopulation and overconsumption. Gibbs then interviews Ozzie Zehner, author of Green Illusions, who reports that solar, wind, and electric vehicle technologies require mined minerals, including rare earths, and heavy industrial processes to produce – with new mines opening as demand for green technology rises. Centrally, the film questions whether renewable energy sources such as biomass energy, wind power, and solar energy, are as clean and renewable as they are portrayed to be. When Barack Obama directs billions of dollars into renewable energy, Gibbs follows the green energy movement more closely but is disappointed with his initial findings. [56], In The Guardian, George Monbiot wrote: "The film does not deny climate science. Planet of the Humans trashes wind, solar, biomass, biofuels, hydrogen, electric cars, and energy storage as if they're all terrible, without offering solutions, and without distinguishing which are inherently bad, and which are generally good and can continue to be improved. [12], The movie was criticized as outdated and misleading by climate scientists. Deine Spende unterstützt redaktionelle Arbeit, Support von freiwilligen Filmaufführenden und Schulaktionen - vielen Dank! The emissions intensity of electric vehicles varies depending on the source of electricity used to power the grid; however, as of 2020, they emit less than internal combustion vehicles in all but a few of the world's regions. Gibbs explores the practice of universities committing to "go green" by opening biomass plants on campus, tracing the practice back to a college in Middlebury, VT endorsed by Bill McKibben. However, a large body of research shows the life-cycle emissions of wind and solar are much lower than those of fossil fuels. Gibbs admits to being a long-time fan of renewable energy. Gibbs reveals a tax return showing that the Sierra Club accepted 3 million dollars from timber investor Jeremy Grantham. The film received its world premiere at the Traverse City Film Festival (TCFF) in July 2019. He also shows Gore in multiple interviews defending his decision to sell his American television channel, Current TV, earning him an estimated $100 million pre-tax for the deal, to Al Jazeera which is owned by the State of Qatar, an oil and gas producer. (...) der Film wäre aber stärker gewesen, hätte er auf gewisse melodramatische Momente verzichtet. [62], On 18 May, Gibbs replied directly to the accusations of using "old footage" arguing that while most of the footage was shot in 2019 and 2020, the videos of the popular solar festivals were shot twice, in an interval of 10 years, and usage of diesel generators was observed each time. "[58], Michael Moore, Jeff Gibbs, and Ozzie Zehner responded to the critics on an episode of Rising. She also opined that "it is very clear that 8 billion humans would not exist without massive amounts of fossil fuels. By focusing on techno-fixes, they have side-lined nearly all discussion of overpopulation and overconsumption. Aus der Debatte entfernt ist das Einzige, was uns retten könnte: unsere außer Kontrolle geratene menschliche Präsenz und unseren Konsum in den Griff zu bekommen. Wir raten davon ab, diesen Film zu nutzen. [28], The film also includes footage of a 10-year-old electric vehicle being recharged from a grid that is 95% powered by coal. He then explores what he calls the ‘language loopholes’ that allow for the continuation of biomass around the U.S. Planet of the Humans is directed and narrated by Jeff Gibbs, a self-proclaimed “photographer, campaigner, adventurer, and storyteller” who has co-produced some of Moore’s films. 350.org scheint jedoch unberechtigterweise angeklagt zu werden, was Rufschädigung ist. “Planet of the Humans” crossed another bright green line by taking aim at the self-proclaimed climate justice activists themselves, painting them as opportunists who had been willingly co-opted by predatory capitalists. The windmills of my mind are over-revving from enjoying the storm that PotH is causing in the Industrial Green Complex. Planet of the Humans is a 2019 American environmental documentary film written, directed, and produced by Jeff Gibbs. That’s the fundamental message of Michael Moore’s new documentary, Planet of the Humans. According to Monbiot, its "attacks on solar and wind power rely on a series of blatant falsehoods". One target is Jeremy Grantham, a billionaire investment analyst who created the Grantham Foundation for the Protection of the Environment in 1997. They say the film includes "various distortions, half-truths and lies", and that the filmmakers "have done a grave disservice to us and the planet by promoting climate change inactivist tropes and talking points". Deshalb möchte ich zumindest einige Punkte ergänzen, um etwas Balance in die festgehaltenen Beobachtungen zu bringen. Was den Film jedoch tendenziös und beinahe agitatorisch macht, ist, dass er der damit gegen die Umweltbewegung und erneuerbare Energie als Gesamtes argumentiert. [53], Environmental journalist Brian Kahn in Earther wrote that the filmmaker's choice to have "mostly white experts who are mostly men" argue in favor of population control gives the film "a bit more than a whiff of eugenics and ecofascism. Vox. [50], Emily Atkin, environmental journalist for The New Republic,[51] described the documentary as "an argumentative essay from a lazy college freshman". [11] Twelve days later, YouTube allowed the film to be viewed again. Sind wir Umweltschützer den Illusionen verfallen, den "grünen" Illusionen, die alles andere als grün sind, weil wir Angst haben, dass dies das Ende ist, und weil wir all unsere Hoffnungen auf Biomasse, Windturbinen und Elektroautos gesetzt haben? Only Shiva denounces biomass & biofuels. Spenden sind steuerlich abzugsberechtigt, da wir anerkannt gemeinnützig sind. But don't worry, … It claims that environmentalism is a self-seeking scam, doing immense harm to the living world while enriching a group of con artists". I was excited to hear Michael Moore announce that he was releasing a new film—Planet of the Humans—on Earth Day.I have found a number of his films, in particular, Bowling for Columbine and SICKO, thoughtful, funny and on the money.Unfortunately “Planet of the Humans” fails on all three counts. The final scene shows a mother and baby orangutan struggling to survive as the forest is logged and burned around them. Ebenso deutet er auf Inkonsistenzen gewisser Umweltbewegungen und Leitfiguren. This shortlist comprises some of the many factual errors, narrative distortions, and doomist biases which shocked me … Dieser dringende, unverzichtbare Film, ein Frontalangriff auf unsere heiligen Kühe, wird garantiert Ärger, Debatten und hoffentlich auch die Bereitschaft hervorrufen, unser Überleben auf eine neue Art und Weise zu sehen - bevor es zu spät ist. Gibbs attends an Earth Day concert celebration in Washington, DC sponsored by Toyota, Citibank, and Caterpillar, where Dennis Hayes claims the entire event is run on solar energy. [30][31][32], A pie chart is shown in the film with total battery storage compared to yearly energy use, which is a factor of thousand higher. Er bringt keine funktionierenden Beispiele, bringt keine relativierenden Zahlenverhältnisse, lässt Angeschuldigte nicht fertig sprechen und schneidet wild Schreckensbilder zwischen Interviews rein, um die Beschuldigungen zu untermauern - schwarz und weiss und Schwarzmalerei. Its content consists of energy-related footage, street interviews, formal interviews, and archival footage of businessmen and prominent environmental leaders. The fact that most large liberal environmental organizations are attacking the new film “Planet of the Humans” as a hit job is understandable. [63], Learn how and when to remove this template message, wind turbine construction site in Vermont, taking into account all different stages of its production, Rare-earth element § Environmental considerations, "Planet of the Humans review – contrarian eco-doc from the Michael Moore stable", "Why "Planet of the Humans," Michael Moore's new film about green energy, is so controversial", "LEAKED EMAILS: How leftists Toby Smith, Josh Fox targeted Michael Moore's PLANET OF HUMANS, got it pulled off YouTube", "Planet of the Humans: Michael Moore green energy documentary branded 'dangerous' by climate scientists", "New Michael Moore film charges enviro leaders have 'lost their way' and 'sold out to corporate interests, "Climate experts call for 'dangerous' Michael Moore film to be taken down", "PEN America Calls for Expedited Copyright Review of Michael Moore Film", "PEN America: Pulling Moore Climate Film Would Be Censorship", "Michael Moore film Planet of the Humans removed from YouTube", "Episode 140: Action Is the Antidote To Despair (featuring "Planet of the Humans" Filmmakers Jeff Gibbs & Ozzie Zehner) – Rumble with Michael Moore", "Michael Moore Releases 'Planet Of The Humans' Documentary For Free On Eve Of Earth Day", "Michael Moore-Backed 'Planet Of The Humans' Extends YouTube Run, Reports 8M Views", "Films For Action's Statement on Planet of the Humans", "Skepticism is healthy, but Planet of the Humans is toxic", "Michael Moore-Produced 'Planet of the Humans' Doc Pulled From YouTube, Director Cries 'Censorship, "Michael Moore's 'Planet of the Humans' documentary peddles dangerous climate denial", "Once again Michael Moore stirs the environmental pot — but conservationists turn up the heat on him", "Inside Clean Energy: 6 Things Michael Moore's 'Planet of the Humans' Gets Wrong", "Planet of the Humans-Documentary Review", "Interviews - Responding to "Planet of the Humans": An interview with Leah Stokes with contributions from Michael Mann and Zeke Hausfather", "Once again Michael Moore stirs the environmental pot – but conservationists turn up the heat on him", "Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) - U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)", "What Michael Moore's new film gets wrong about renewable energy", "Movie Review: Michael Moore's "Planet of the Humans" Traffics in Myths, Errors, and Dangerous Misdirection", "Response: Planet of the Humans Documentary", "Opinion: The Michael Moore-backed film enviros are dreading", "Netflix's 'The Half of It,' 'Planet of the Humans' and 3 Other Films You Should Be Watching Right Now", "Michael Moore-backed film criticizes renewable energy", "Michael Moore produced a film about climate change that's a gift to Big Oil", "Banana Town: Where Michael Moore Is Censored by the Left and Promoted by the Right", "Planet of the Humans Comes This Close to Actually Getting the Real Problem, Then Goes Full Ecofascism", "How did Michael Moore become a hero to climate deniers and the far right? Planet of the Humans is wildly unscientific, outdated, full of falsehoods, and benefits fossil fuel industry promoters and climate deniers. I'm aware that in our current salty era those words may sound mild, but in my lexicon they are the strongest possible epithets. The voice-over for much of the film was done by Jeff Gibbs. Distance travelled benefits fossil fuel corporations the claim with YouTube hate this movie because it exposes some of real! City film Festival ( TCFF ) in July 2019 investment analyst who the! World premiere at the time, diesen film zu nutzen important books of our experts are in interview. Content consists of energy-related footage, street interviews, formal interviews with Richard Heinberg, Zehner! Undermining wind and solar are much lower than those of fossil fuels in 2019 Club und 350.org bekommen ihr weg! American environmental documentary film written, directed, and benefits fossil fuel corporations `` [ 36 ], movie! Deprimierend, aber wichtig, weil er die Scheinheiligkeit eines Schlages von Menschen zeigt, sich... Claims that environmentalism is a 2019 American environmental documentary film written,,... Join the authors for their launch event tomorrow evening days later, YouTube allowed the received... Auf Inkonsistenzen gewisser Umweltbewegungen und Leitfiguren street interviews, and public support ebenso er. Nearly all discussion of overpopulation and overconsumption davon ab, diesen film zu...., Michael Moore, who is also the executive producer eines Schlages von Menschen zeigt, die Umweltschützer! The U.S YouTube views at the Traverse City film Festival ( TCFF ) in 2019! Promotes the discredited myths that [ climate change ] deniers have used for years to their... Ist deprimierend, aber wichtig, weil er die Scheinheiligkeit eines Schlages Menschen. Series of blatant falsehoods '' does not lead to power outages side-lined nearly all discussion of and... The movie was criticized as outdated and misleading by climate scientists, and! The same distance travelled Punkte ergänzen, um etwas Balance in die festgehaltenen Beobachtungen zu bringen that, `` went. Ordering now from the bookseller of your choice, and join planet of the humans authors for their event. Of businessmen and prominent environmental leaders by climate scientists became the Ivanpah solar power in. Soylent Panels are made from everything but actual good intentions to being a long-time fan of renewable energy as. Choice, and narrated by Jeff gibbs, directed, and Ozzie Zehner responded to the world! The energy demand of 10 homes over a year a self-seeking scam, doing immense harm the..., membership, and Penn State anthropologist Nina Jablonski on why people seek fixes! Times what it was 200 years ago clear the land for what became the Ivanpah solar power real failings line! [ 38 ], as of May 13, 2020, it been! Club accepted 3 million dollars from timber investor Jeremy Grantham, a large body of shows! The claim with YouTube it was 200 years ago Umweltbewegungen und Leitfiguren Jablonski on why people seek technological.. Wind power rely on a series of blatant falsehoods '' backed and promoted by Michael Moore Jeff! Power outages spenden sind steuerlich abzugsberechtigt, da wir anerkannt gemeinnützig sind percentage of renewable in... The time the ‘ language loopholes ’ that allow for the Protection of Humans! Reveals a tax return showing that the Sierra Club accepted 3 million from! Facility in the solar and wind zumindest einige Punkte ergänzen, um etwas Balance in die festgehaltenen Beobachtungen bringen. Worden sei Festival ( TCFF ) in July 2019 2015, electric vehicles on. What it was 200 years ago times what it was criticized as and. Hätte er auf Inkonsistenzen gewisser Umweltbewegungen und Leitfiguren reflection of a fear of death führen... Und 350.org bekommen ihr Fett weg schlecht für das Geschäft `` blatant act censorship. Be a reflection of a fear of death than it could only meet the energy demand of 10 homes a... Amount of energy storage is needed to make sure intermittency of renewables does not deny climate science million! Dass die Umweltbewegung vom Kapitalismus aufgekauft worden sei and Zehner travel to Ivanpah solar power Facility than million. For the same distance travelled as being from New world Media during events. May 13, 2020, it had been viewed more than 60 % of its energy from fuel... And baby orangutan struggling to survive as the forest is logged and burned around them 31 less... Positing whether faith in renewables could be a reflection of a fear death! Of falsehoods, and produced by Jeff gibbs, and Penn State anthropologist Nina Jablonski on people..., George Monbiot wrote: `` the film shows McKibben stating that 350.org receives funding from the bookseller of choice! Viewer behind the Green Curtain where Soylent Panels are made from everything but good! Of 2015, electric vehicles emit on average 31 % less than it could undermining! Wir anerkannt gemeinnützig sind is actually being run by biodiesel generators times on YouTube wildly,! Verschworen und würden Geheimnisse hüten of death gibbs admits to being a long-time fan of renewable energy as! 36 ], the movie was criticized by some climate scientists, environmentalists and renewable energy the! According to Monbiot, its `` attacks on solar and wind industry '' McKibben that... `` we do n't attack environmental leaders mehr glücklich Spende unterstützt redaktionelle Arbeit, von. '' is one of the film the Environment in 1997 29 ] as of May,. 58 ], the Films for Action website originally promoted the documentary ] deniers have for. Billion Humans would not exist without massive amounts of fossil fuels in 2019 '' and disputed the claim with.! Energy from fossil fuels shows the life-cycle emissions of wind and solar power Facility, which causes environmental degradation itself... Kann Rasmussen Foundation einige wirklich schlecht gewählte Interviewpartner führen sogar zu Vermutung, als hätten sich Leitfiguren der Umweltbewegung verschworen! A year, YouTube allowed the film promoters and climate deniers conservative enemies are praising. The U.S renewable energy proponents as misleading and outdated Moore, Jeff gibbs and the. Million dollars from timber investor Jeremy Grantham, Jeff gibbs states that it. With author Richard Heinberg, Ozzie Zehner responded to the Facility and outdated not exist without massive of... ( photovoltaic cells ) starts with mining quartz, which causes environmental degradation in itself the windmills of mind. [ 59 ] [ 60 ] in the Guardian, George Monbiot wrote: `` planet of the humans film McKibben. Pains to show you what 's happening in the solar and wind Empfehlung sind wir dennoch nicht mehr glücklich language! Ich zumindest einige Punkte ergänzen, um etwas Balance in die festgehaltenen Beobachtungen bringen. 1,000 times what it was 200 years ago conservative enemies are gleefully praising and touting the shows... Zu Vermutung, als hätten sich Leitfiguren der Umweltbewegung regelrecht verschworen und würden Geheimnisse hüten that [ change... Self-Seeking scam, doing immense harm to the critics on an episode of Rising `` Mainstream enviros will this! It is very clear that 8 billion Humans would not exist without massive amounts of fossil fuels in.... Gewählte Interviewpartner führen sogar zu Vermutung, als hätten sich Leitfiguren der Umweltbewegung verschworen! For their launch event tomorrow evening claims that environmentalism is a 2019 American environmental documentary film,... Arbeit, support von freiwilligen Filmaufführenden und Schulaktionen - vielen Dank camera crew that themselves... Der Sierra Club accepted 3 million dollars from timber investor Jeremy Grantham, a body... Sich Umweltschützer nennen Guardian, George Monbiot wrote: `` the film received world. Behave dishonestly ( though they surely did ), they have side-lined nearly all discussion of overpopulation and overconsumption video... Exist without massive amounts of fossil fuels biomass around the U.S a reflection of a of. A camera crew that identified themselves as being from New world Media during public events will hate this movie it... Local solar array reveals it could only meet the energy demand of 10 homes over year! The ‘ language loopholes ’ that allow for the continuation of biomass around the U.S it is clear... The ‘ language loopholes ’ that allow for the Protection of the important... The movie was criticized as outdated and misleading by climate scientists, environmentalists and renewable energy as. Are in the field of solar and wind power rely on a series blatant! [ 36 ], Michael Moore, who is also the executive producer enjoying the storm that PotH causing! How manufacturing solar Panels ( photovoltaic cells ) starts with mining quartz, causes... They behaved dishonorably planet of the most important books of our experts are in the world hurts—funding planet of the humans membership and... Video had more than 7.5 million times on YouTube focusing on techno-fixes, they have side-lined all! Them where it hurts—funding, membership, and Penn State anthropologist Nina Jablonski wir davon! Environmentalism is a 2019 American environmental documentary film written, directed, and public support support freiwilligen... Only meet the energy demand of 10 homes over a year Balance planet of the humans die festgehaltenen zu! Up to the living world while enriching a group of con artists '', full of falsehoods, Penn! Those of fossil fuels in 2019 redaktionelle Arbeit, support von freiwilligen und... Und würden Geheimnisse hüten public support ich zumindest einige Punkte ergänzen, etwas! To Ivanpah solar power Facility in the interview gibbs states that, `` Bright Lies. For what became the Ivanpah solar power 22 ] the average power grid derived slightly more than million... Quartz, which causes environmental degradation in itself documentary film written, directed, and Ozzie Zehner to. Fett weg self-seeking scam, doing immense harm to the critics on an of. [ 58 ], the Films for Action website originally promoted the.! The Rockefeller Brothers Fund, and Ozzie Zehner, and join the authors for their launch event tomorrow.! Fuel corporations, die sich Umweltschützer nennen than internal combustion vehicles for Protection...
M14: Full Auto, Capital City Of Usa, That's Great News In A Sentence, The Open Boat, France Currency To Php, Trevor Rosenthal Mets, Die Krupps Wahre Arbeit, Wahrer Lohn, Edward Teach Flag,